After three separate guest performances and a lot of extended chatter, American Idol 9 lost its first finalist: Lacey Brown. That was as unsurprising as the bottom three, which also included Paige Miles and Tim Urban. If there was any surprise, it was that Tim wasn’t in the bottom two, and when Ryan Seacrest sent him back to safety, he gave us that now-familiar look of surprise that appears on his face every time he…
More here:
Lacey Brown out of Idol as judges’ save returns, Seacrest spoils results for west coast

